Insights
Gartner alternative: what a Magic Quadrant leaves for you to do
A Magic Quadrant is a starting point, not an evaluation. Four gaps it leaves for you, and what a side-by-side evaluation adds.
A Magic Quadrant is a useful place to start. It is not an evaluation of your options. You still run the evaluation, and your board will still ask why you picked Vendor X for your environment. Here are four gaps, and what we do about each.
A note on who is writing: IQ4hire is an independent technology advisory. We compete for the same decision, so read this with that in mind.
Gartner's research is useful. It also sits on a business model worth understanding before you rely on it for a decision you may have to defend.
The coverage gap
Gartner says a Magic Quadrant evaluates the vendors that meet the inclusion criteria it sets for that market. That is a sound way to track the major players. It also means a provider that does not meet those criteria is not on the page, however well it might fit you. An emerging or niche provider can be the best fit for your environment and still be absent.
The process gap
A research report is not an evaluation. The research subscription gives you the research. It does not run your RFP, score vendor responses, host demonstrations, negotiate your contract or stay involved through go-live. Gartner sells other services separately. That work stays with you unless you buy them.
The money gap
Gartner earns revenue from enterprise subscriptions and, separately, from vendors, through advisory relationships and events. Gartner states that client status and spending are not factors in who is included or how they are positioned (Gartner's Magic Quadrant FAQ). We have no reason to doubt that. The concern is structural, not a claim of bias: you should know who pays whom before you rely on a ranking.
That applies to us too, so here is how we are paid. Suppliers don't pay to be listed. If you buy through us, the supplier you choose pays IQ4hire, and we tell you before work begins.
The board gap
"We used Gartner" tells your board where you found a research report. It does not explain why you chose Vendor X over Vendor Y, at your price, in your environment. A documented, side-by-side evaluation does. That is the difference between a citation and a defense.
What we do instead
We work in three steps: find, fit, execute. An RFP only when the decision needs one.
(opens the full-size image in a new tab)
Head to head
| What matters | A Magic Quadrant subscription | IQ4hire |
|---|---|---|
| How it is paid | Client subscription. Gartner also earns revenue from vendors in other ways. | The supplier you choose pays IQ4hire. We tell you before work begins. |
| What you get | Research on the vendors that meet its inclusion criteria | A short list from 500+ vetted vendors |
| Coverage | One market at a time | 25 categories, software and services. Hardware on request. |
| Evaluating your options | Not part of the research subscription | Side-by-side scoring of vendor responses |
| Contract negotiation | Not part of the research subscription | Part of our service |
| Go-live support | Not part of the research subscription | Part of our service |
| What you show your board | A research citation | A documented, side-by-side evaluation of your options |
What this means for your decision
A Magic Quadrant is a good starting point. The evaluation, the negotiation and the defense are still yours. We do those three, side by side, and we tell you how we are paid before work begins.
The full comparison, with how each option is paid and what each includes, is on our Gartner alternative page. To see how it works on your decision, schedule a diagnostic.
Sources
- Gartner, FAQ: How Markets and Vendors Are Evaluated in Gartner Magic Quadrants
- IQ4hire's own experience running technology selections.
Gartner and Magic Quadrant are registered trademarks of Gartner, Inc. and/or its affiliates, used here only to name the product. IQ4hire is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Gartner.
